Ford Mustang Mach-E vs Tesla Model Y

How the Ford Mustang Mach-E and Tesla Model Y compare for Canadian buyers: trims by budget, range and charging, driving feel, phone and screen tech, and which one suits the way you drive.

Updated

At a Glance

The Ford Mustang Mach-E and Tesla Model Y are five-seat electric SUVs whose price ladders overlap almost from bottom to top. They appeal to different priorities. Ford builds its case on driving character, with all-wheel drive on every trim and drive modes that change how the car feels. Tesla builds its case on getting more distance from less electricity and on its own fast-charging network.

Ford Mustang Mach-E vs Tesla Model Y at a glance
Ford Mustang Mach-ETesla Model Y
MSRP range (CAD)$44,995–$70,495$49,990–$74,990
Canadian trims63
Body styleFive-seat crossoverFive-seat crossover
DrivetrainAWDRWD or AWD
Range380–483 km463–542 km
Power242–358 kW220–380 kW
0–100 km/h3.6–4.9 s3.5–7.2 s
Energy use (combined)20.0–25.0 kWh/100 km15.4–19.2 kWh/100 km
DC fast charging30–36 min (estimate)24–27 min (estimate)
Level 2 charging7 h 42 min–10 h 12 min8 h

Estimate

Ford Mustang Mach-E

The Mach-E carries the Mustang name, tail lights and long-bonnet stance into a five-seat crossover. All six Canadian trims have all-wheel drive. Select and Premium each come with a Standard Range or Extended Range battery, and the GT and Rally sit at the top with the most power. Reviewers describe quick, eager steering, a ride on the firm side and a choice of Whisper, Engage and Unbridle modes.

Tesla Model Y

Tesla offers three Model Y trims here: a rear-drive entry model plus two dual-motor versions, the Premium AWD and the Performance AWD. Its strengths are efficiency and range. Every trim lists lower energy use than any Mach-E, and the car charges natively at Tesla Superchargers, with stops planned by its own navigation.

Choose the Ford Mustang Mach-E if you want all-wheel drive on every trim, Mustang styling, drive modes that change steering, throttle response and sound, a lower-priced way into an AWD electric crossover, and Apple CarPlay or Android Auto on the large portrait screen.

Choose the Tesla Model Y if you want more kilometres from each charge, the lowest listed energy use of any trim here, Tesla's own fast chargers, planned into the car's route guidance for road trips, and a very quick Performance AWD at the top of the range.

Trim Comparison by Budget

About $44,000 to $52,000: All-wheel drive for less or lower energy use

TrimMSRP (CAD)DrivetrainRangePower0–100 km/hEnergy use (combined)DC fast chargingLevel 2 charging
Mustang Mach-E / Model Y Mach-E Select Standard Range$44,995AWD380 km242 kW4.9 s22.3 kWh/100 km30 min (estimate)7 h 42 min
Mustang Mach-E / Model Y Mach-E Premium Standard Range$46,995AWD380 km242 kW4.9 s22.3 kWh/100 km30 min (estimate)7 h 42 min
Mustang Mach-E / Model Y Mach-E Select Extended Range$48,995AWD483 km272 kW4.4 s20.0 kWh/100 km36 min (estimate)10 h 12 min
Model Y RWD$49,990RWD463 km220 kW7.2 s15.4 kWh/100 km24 min (estimate)8 h
Mustang Mach-E / Model Y Mach-E Premium Extended Range$51,995AWD483 km272 kW4.4 s20.0 kWh/100 km36 min (estimate)10 h 12 min

Estimate

What stands out

  • If you want all-wheel drive for the least money: every Mach-E in this band has all-wheel drive, and the Model Y RWD is the only rear-drive trim. The Mach-E Select Standard Range is the lowest-priced trim on this page, and Ford lists it at 4.9 seconds to 100 km/h against 7.2 seconds for the Model Y RWD.
  • If range at this price matters: the Mach-E Select Extended Range and Premium Extended Range list 483 km, 20 km more than the Model Y RWD. The Standard Range trims list 380 km, 83 km less, and cost less again.
  • If running cost per kilometre matters: at 15.4 kWh/100 km combined, the Model Y RWD has the lowest listed energy use in this band. The Extended Range Mach-E trims list 20.0 and the Standard Range trims 22.3, so the Mach-E needs more electricity for each kilometre.
  • If you want ventilated front seats: Ford lists them on the Premium Standard Range and Premium Extended Range. Neither is on the Model Y RWD.
  • If you rely on phone mirroring: every Mach-E in this band lists Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. The Model Y supports neither.

About $64,000 to $75,000: Performance and long-range picks

TrimMSRP (CAD)DrivetrainRangePower0–100 km/hEnergy use (combined)DC fast chargingLevel 2 charging
Model Y Premium AWD$64,990AWD542 km296 kW4.6 s17.3 kWh/100 km27 min (estimate)8 h
Mustang Mach-E / Model Y Mach-E GT$64,995AWD451 km358 kW4.0 s23.2 kWh/100 km36 min (estimate)9 h 54 min
Mustang Mach-E / Model Y Mach-E Rally$70,495AWD410 km358 kW3.6 s25.0 kWh/100 km36 min (estimate)9 h 54 min
Model Y Performance AWD$74,990AWD494 km380 kW3.5 s19.2 kWh/100 km27 min (estimate)8 h

Estimate

What stands out

  • If you are choosing between the GT and the Premium AWD: they are priced about the same. The GT lists 62 kW more and reaches 100 km/h 0.6 seconds sooner. The Premium AWD lists 91 km more range and 17.3 kWh/100 km against the GT's 23.2.
  • If you want the longest range here: no trim on this page goes further than the Model Y Premium AWD's listed 542 km, and it also uses the least energy in this band.
  • If you are weighing the two top trims: the Rally costs less than the Model Y Performance AWD. The Performance AWD lists 22 kW more and 84 km more range, and both are quoted at well under four seconds to 100 km/h.
  • If tire size matters to you: the Rally rides on 19-inch tires with a taller 55-series sidewall, the GT on 20-inch tires, and the Model Y Performance AWD on 21-inch wheels.
  • If heated rear seats matter: both Model Y trims in this band list them, along with ventilated front seats. For the GT, Ford lists heated front seats, a heated steering wheel and wireless phone charging.

EVSearch Verdict

Vehicle-level guidance

Pick the Mach-E if the way a car steers and responds matters more to you than kilometres per charge. Every trim drives all four wheels, its Whisper, Engage and Unbridle modes reshape its personality, and the GT and Rally deliver serious pace. Pick the Model Y if covering long distances on less electricity and stopping at Tesla's own chargers come first. The GT and Model Y Premium AWD are priced about the same, so that pairing is the sharpest decision on this page.

Recommended trims

  • Lowest-priced AWD: Mach-E Select Standard Range. It is the lowest-priced trim on this page and still has all-wheel drive, with 380 km of listed range.
  • AWD with more range: Mach-E Select Extended Range. It lists more range than the Model Y RWD, adds all-wheel drive and costs a little less.
  • Most range: Model Y Premium AWD. It lists 542 km, the longest range here.
  • Sportiest drive: Mach-E GT. It lists more power and quicker acceleration than the similarly priced Model Y Premium AWD, with 20-inch tires and the adaptive dampers reviewers describe.
  • Quickest: Model Y Performance AWD for the most power and range at the top, or the Mach-E Rally for less money on taller-sidewall tires.

Final buying guidance

  • Drive both on the same day and switch the Mach-E through Whisper, Engage and Unbridle. If the sharper modes are what win you over, the Mach-E's case gets stronger.
  • Count how often you drive long highway trips. The more you rely on fast charging, the more the Model Y's efficiency and its own charging network count.
  • Choose your Mach-E battery by commute and charging access. Extended Range adds about 100 km over Standard Range, which matters most if you can't charge at home every night.
  • With two or three trims left, put your finalists head to head to see their range, power and charging side by side.
Ford Mustang Mach-E exterior
Ford Mustang Mach-E
Tesla Model Y on the road
Tesla Model Y

Range, Battery & Charging

In the Mach-E vs Model Y range battle, the Model Y wins on paper. Its RWD lists 463 km, the Premium AWD 542 km and the Performance AWD 494 km. On the Mach-E, Ford lists 380 km for the Standard Range trims, 483 km for the Extended Range trims, 451 km for the GT and 410 km for the Rally. Only the Extended Range Mach-E outlasts the Model Y RWD, by 20 km.

The bigger gap is energy use. Ford lists 20.0 to 25.0 kWh/100 km combined across the Mach-E lineup, while the Model Y lists 15.4 to 19.2 kWh/100 km. One magazine reviewer singles out the Model Y's efficiency as unusually good for an SUV body. Using more energy per kilometre means each kilometre costs more to charge, whether at home or on the road.

EVSearch estimates about 30 minutes on DC fast chargers for the Standard Range Mach-E and about 36 minutes for the Extended Range, GT and Rally, against about 24 minutes for the Model Y RWD and 27 minutes for the Premium AWD and Performance AWD. These figures cover different battery sizes and charge windows, so they are not a ranking of which car is quicker at a charger. For the Model Y, the bigger advantage is the network: it plugs straight into Tesla's Superchargers, and reviewers point to how reliable and plentiful those stations are on a long trip. For the Mach-E, look at the public charging stations along the routes you drive most often before you buy.

At home, Ford lists a 0% to 100% Level 2 charge at 7 hours 42 minutes for the Standard Range and at 9 hours 54 minutes for the GT and Rally, with the standard 48-amp onboard charger. Natural Resources Canada lists 10 hours 12 minutes for the Extended Range Select and Premium; Ford Canada does not publish an extended-range eAWD Level 2 time for those versions. Tesla lists 8 hours for every Model Y. Either one fits overnight home charging. One GT reviewer notes Ford's advice to charge to 80% for daily use and to 100% only before longer trips.

Driving Experience & Ride Quality

This is where the Mach-E makes its case. Reviewers describe quick, eager steering and a car that corners fluently, and one reviewer calls it a driver's electric SUV. Another finds the steering so quick that it feels a little touchy on a commute, even in the calmest mode. The ride is firm. Reviewers say you feel bumps, and they describe more road and wind noise at highway speed than they expected.

Ford Mustang Mach-E exterior
Ford Mustang Mach-E
Tesla Model Y on the road
Tesla Model Y

The drive modes are central to the Mach-E's character. Whisper is the quiet setting for daily driving, Engage is the balanced middle and Unbridle sharpens throttle and steering response and adds a louder propulsion sound. One reviewer shows the GT's extended Unbridle setting, intended for track use, with an even stronger sound. One-pedal driving can be turned on or off. Reviewers of the GT describe adaptive dampers and very strong acceleration. One reviewer prefers the quiet Whisper mode for everyday driving and saves Unbridle for weekend fun, so a buyer who mostly commutes should spend much of a test drive in Whisper, the mode they would use most.

The Model Y is the calmer drive. One magazine test finds the ride softer than the previous version but still firm over bumps, with wind noise well controlled on the highway. Its steering is quick and it turns into corners keenly. That reviewer says the steering doesn't tell you much about the road, and says you often have to return the wheel to centre yourself. An owner of a rear-drive version says it handles turns well, with tight steering that feels lighter than on Tesla's sportier cars. The difference is one of temperament: the Mach-E rewards a keen driver but asks you to accept a firmer, noisier ride, while the Model Y keeps the cabin calmer and involves the driver less.

Interior, Passenger Space & Practicality

The Mach-E's sloping roof cuts into rear headroom for one reviewer. Others find the back seat roomier than it looks: a 5-foot-11 reviewer has plenty of leg and headroom under the glass roof, and a 6-foot-3 passenger fits comfortably in another test. Reviewers point out that the glass roof has no sunshade; try the back seat on a bright day before you decide. Ford lists ventilated front seats on the Premium trims, and reviewers praise the supportive GT performance seats. One reviewer says those GT seats really hug you, and another finds them extremely comfortable. The gear selector sits on the steering column, leaving open storage in the console.

Both list about the same cargo space behind the rear seats: 840 L in the Mach-E and 822 to 835 L in the Model Y. With the seats folded, the Model Y lists 2,004 to 2,022 L, against 1,674 to 1,690 L for the Mach-E. Measuring methods can vary between brands, so check your own gear in each. Several reviewers find no front trunk on their Mach-E test cars because Ford sells the cover and storage as an option. Every Model Y reviewer shows a front trunk, and one reviewer finds plenty of room in it.

Tesla equips the Model Y Premium AWD and Performance AWD with ventilated front seats and heated rear seats, while the RWD skips both. One reviewer likes the upright driving position and notes that, with no instrument display behind the wheel, you can set the steering wheel wherever suits you.

Technology, Infotainment & Driver Assistance

The Mach-E uses a 15.5-inch portrait touchscreen with the climate controls along the bottom edge, plus a physical dial for volume. One reviewer likes how tactile that dial feels, and another uses it as a multifunction control. A 10.2-inch digital cluster sits behind the wheel. Ford lists Apple CarPlay and Android Auto on the Select, Premium and GT trims, and reviewers use them wirelessly. The GT also lists a surround-view camera and wireless phone charging. Reviewers find the drive modes and one-pedal setting inside the vehicle menu.

The Model Y does not offer Apple CarPlay or Android Auto. Its software runs on the centre touchscreen, with two scroll wheels on the steering wheel: one for audio and one for settings such as temperature and brightness. Reviewers say most adjustments, from mirrors to climate, happen on the screen. Buyers who prefer physical controls will find more of them in the Mach-E, while in the Model Y, getting comfortable with the screen-centric layout is part of the test drive.

Ford lists automatic emergency braking, forward collision warning, lane departure warning, blind-spot monitoring and adaptive cruise control on the Select, Premium and GT trims.

Exterior Design, Body Style & Size

The Mach-E borrows Mustang cues: Mustang-style tail lights, broad rear haunches, a long bonnet and a roof that slopes to a short tail. The GT adds a gloss-black front treatment. Push-button door releases replace conventional handles, and one reviewer finds them fiddly. Tesla takes the opposite approach, with a smooth body and very little decoration. The Mach-E looks deliberately sporty, while the Model Y's plainer shape suits buyers who prefer a quieter design.

Ford Mustang Mach-E exterior
Ford Mustang Mach-E
Tesla Model Y side profile
Tesla Model Y

The Model Y is the wider car, at 1,920 to 1,921 mm wide, about 40 mm more than the Mach-E's 1,881 mm. The Mach-E's 2,983 to 2,984 mm wheelbase is 93 to 94 mm longer than the Model Y's. The Rally is the tallest trim on this page at 1,648 mm. Ford fits 19-inch tires on the Select and Premium, 20-inch tires on the GT and 19-inch tires on the Rally. Model Y wheels range from 18 inches on the RWD through 19 inches on the Premium AWD to 21 inches on the Performance AWD.

What to Check on a Test Drive

  • How each car's steering feels in your daily traffic, and whether the Mach-E's quick steering stays enjoyable in Whisper mode.
  • The difference between the Mach-E's Whisper, Engage and Unbridle modes, including the propulsion sound.
  • Ride comfort and road noise over broken pavement, especially on the GT's 20-inch and the Model Y Performance AWD's 21-inch wheels.
  • Rear headroom under each sloping roof for your tallest passengers, and glare from each glass roof on a sunny day.
  • Whether the Mach-E you're looking at has the optional front storage, and what you'd actually store under the Model Y's bonnet.
  • Your phone with Apple CarPlay or Android Auto in the Mach-E, and how you'd manage without mirroring in the Model Y.
  • Route planning on a long trip in each car, including where the Mach-E's planner sends you for fast charging.

Ready to compare them in person?

Ford Mustang Mach-EBook a Test Drive
Tesla Model YBook a Test Drive

Notes

  • Some reviews summarized here cover versions sold outside Canada. Trim names, features and figures not listed for Canadian trims are not used.

Prices, trims and specs come from EVSearch's Canadian vehicle data. Driving impressions summarize published expert reviews. Prices are MSRP before freight, fees, taxes and incentives.

Compare

Book a test drive

    I'm interested in:












    To find your nearest dealer.



    By submitting, you agree that EVSearch and its partners may contact you about this request. PrivacyTerms