Hyundai IONIQ 5 vs Tesla Model Y

How the Hyundai IONIQ 5 and Tesla Model Y compare for Canadian buyers: price, range, charging, cabin space and everyday usability.

Updated

At a Glance

The Hyundai IONIQ 5 and Tesla Model Y are two-row, five-seat electric SUVs at similar prices. Both offer RWD and AWD. The Model Y starts lower and lists more range at most price points. The IONIQ 5 has the more flexible cabin, physical buttons and phone mirroring. Its lineup also includes the high-performance N.

Hyundai IONIQ 5 vs Tesla Model Y at a glance
Hyundai IONIQ 5Tesla Model Y
MSRP range (CAD)$55,499–$78,199$49,990–$74,990
Canadian trims53
DrivetrainRWD or AWDRWD or AWD
Battery options84 kWh64 or 82 kWh
Range356–504 km463–542 km
Power168–478 kW (figure with N Grin Boost engaged)220–380 kW
DC fast charging18 min24–27 min (estimate)

Figure with N Grin Boost engagedEstimate

Hyundai IONIQ 5

Hyundai's IONIQ 5 is a boxy, upright crossover on a long wheelbase. All five Canadian trims share one battery: a single RWD trim, three AWD trims and the high-performance N. It is calm and comfortable, with a flat floor, a sliding console and a sliding rear seat.

Tesla Model Y

The Model Y is Tesla's electric crossover. The latest version has new front and rear styling, a quieter cabin and a softer ride than before. The Canadian lineup is short: a RWD trim with a smaller battery, the Premium AWD and the Performance AWD. Its strengths are storage, fast and polished software, and charging stops planned by its own navigation. Almost every control sits on the central touchscreen.

Choose the Hyundai IONIQ 5 if you want a roomy, flexible family cabin with a sliding rear seat, physical buttons and wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, a calm and relaxed drive, or a dedicated performance trim in the N.

Choose the Tesla Model Y if you want the lowest entry price, more range for similar money, deep under-floor storage with a usable front trunk, and Tesla's navigation planning your charging stops, and you are happy with a screen-based cabin.

Trim Comparison by Budget

About $49,000 to $56,000: Lowest-priced versions

TrimMSRP (CAD)DrivetrainBatteryRangePowerTorque0–100 km/hDC fast chargingLevel 2 charging
Model Y RWD$49,990RWD64 kWh463 km220 kW404 Nm7.2 s24 min (estimate)8 h
IONIQ 5 Preferred Long Range RWD$55,499RWD84 kWh504 km168 kW350 Nm7.5 s18 min7 h 20 min (hyundai figure for a 10–100% charge with the standard 10.9 kW onboard charger)

EstimateHyundai figure for a 10–100% charge with the standard 10.9 kW onboard charger

What stands out

  • If price matters most, the Model Y RWD is the lowest-priced trim in either lineup. It costs $5,509 less than the IONIQ 5 and lists more power and torque.
  • If you want the most range from a RWD trim, the IONIQ 5 lists 41 km more from its larger 84 kWh battery, so the extra money mainly buys range.

About $57,000 to $65,000: Everyday AWD and equipment upgrades

TrimMSRP (CAD)DrivetrainBatteryRangePowerTorque0–100 km/hDC fast chargingLevel 2 charging
IONIQ 5 Preferred AWD$57,499AWD84 kWh463 km239 kW605 Nm5.3 s18 min7 h 20 min (hyundai figure for a 10–100% charge with the standard 10.9 kW onboard charger)
IONIQ 5 Trend AWD$59,499AWD84 kWh463 km239 kW605 Nm5.3 s18 min7 h 20 min (hyundai figure for a 10–100% charge with the standard 10.9 kW onboard charger)
IONIQ 5 Ultimate AWD$63,499AWD84 kWh463 km239 kW605 Nm5.3 s18 min7 h 20 min (hyundai figure for a 10–100% charge with the standard 10.9 kW onboard charger)
Model Y Premium AWD$64,990AWD82 kWh542 km296 kW510 Nm4.6 s27 min (estimate)8 h

Hyundai figure for a 10–100% charge with the standard 10.9 kW onboard chargerEstimate

What stands out

  • For the cheapest way into AWD, look at the IONIQ 5 Preferred AWD. No AWD trim in either lineup costs less, and it undercuts the Model Y Premium AWD by $7,491.
  • If range matters most, the Model Y Premium AWD lists 79 km more than the IONIQ 5 AWD trims, with a slightly smaller battery, and more power. It costs $1,491 more than the IONIQ 5 Ultimate AWD.
  • If you want more equipment, the IONIQ 5 Trend AWD and Ultimate AWD list the same battery, range and performance as the Preferred AWD. The extra money buys equipment, not range or performance.

About $74,000 to $79,000: Performance models

TrimMSRP (CAD)DrivetrainBatteryRangePowerTorque0–100 km/hDC fast chargingLevel 2 charging
Model Y Performance AWD$74,990AWD82 kWh494 km380 kW674 Nm3.5 s27 min (estimate)8 h
IONIQ 5 N$78,199AWD84 kWh356 km478 kW (figure with N Grin Boost engaged)770 Nm (figure with N Grin Boost engaged)3.5 s18 min7 h 20 min (hyundai figure for a 10–100% charge with the standard 10.9 kW onboard charger)

EstimateFigure with N Grin Boost engagedHyundai figure for a 10–100% charge with the standard 10.9 kW onboard charger

What stands out

  • If straight-line speed is the goal, the N lists more power and torque with N Grin Boost engaged. Tesla and Hyundai measure 0–100 km/h differently, so the two times are not a direct match.
  • If you want a fast car you can also road-trip, the Model Y Performance AWD lists 138 km more range and costs $3,209 less.
  • If you want a car built mainly for driving enjoyment, the N is Hyundai's dedicated performance model.

EVSearch Verdict

Vehicle-level guidance

Lean toward the Model Y if you want the lowest entry price, more range for similar money, deep cargo storage and charging stops planned by Tesla's navigation. Lean toward the IONIQ 5 if a flexible family cabin, physical buttons, phone mirroring and a calmer ride matter more, or if you want the N. Both offer RWD and AWD. At similar prices the Model Y usually lists more range, so the cabin and controls should decide.

Recommended trims

  • Lowest price: Model Y RWD. It is the lowest-priced trim in either lineup and lists more power and torque than the IONIQ 5 RWD.
  • Most range: Model Y Premium AWD. It lists the most range of any trim in either lineup, with AWD.
  • Lowest-priced AWD: IONIQ 5 Preferred AWD. It is the lowest-priced AWD trim in either lineup. It gives up range to the Model Y Premium AWD but costs much less.
  • Highest-range RWD: IONIQ 5 Preferred Long Range RWD. It lists the most range in the IONIQ 5 lineup and more than the Model Y RWD.
  • Most performance: Model Y Performance AWD for range and price, or IONIQ 5 N for a dedicated performance car.

Final buying guidance

  • Sit in both and try the controls first. A touchscreen-only cabin suits some drivers and frustrates others.
  • Then decide how much range you need for your longest regular trips.
  • Pay for a higher IONIQ 5 AWD trim only if you want its equipment. It does not add range or performance.
  • Once you have narrowed it down to two or three trims, check their specs together in the EVSearch comparison tool.

Range, Battery & Charging

The two take different approaches to batteries. Every IONIQ 5 trim uses the same 84 kWh battery. The Model Y RWD uses a smaller battery, and both Model Y AWD trims use a larger one that is still a little smaller than the IONIQ 5's.

Even so, the Model Y lists more range at most price points. With RWD, the IONIQ 5 lists 41 km more than the Model Y RWD, but it has a much larger battery. With AWD, the Model Y Premium AWD lists 79 km more than the IONIQ 5 AWD trims. The performance trims show the biggest gap. The IONIQ 5 N lists the lowest range of any trim in either lineup.

The difference comes down to efficiency. Where NRCan lists energy use, the Model Y RWD uses less energy per 100 km than the IONIQ 5 RWD. One reviewer was impressed by the Model Y's efficiency in mixed driving. Another owner says the latest Model Y lasts noticeably longer between highway charging stops than the previous version.

Each trim has one DC fast-charging time. Every IONIQ 5 trim lists 18 minutes. The Model Y lists 24 minutes for the RWD and 27 minutes for the AWD trims. Treat DC charging as a rough guide rather than a deciding factor.

How charging works on a trip matters as much as the time. Several Model Y reviewers single out the Supercharger network. You plug in and charging starts, and the car's navigation plans charging stops for you. One reviewer notes that the Model Y's charging speed is now closer to the middle of the pack than ahead of it. The IONIQ 5 now has the same charge-port type as Tesla, with adapters included for other plug types.

The Level 2 times in the tables are on two different bases. Every Model Y trim lists NRCan's 8 h for a full charge. For every IONIQ 5 trim, Hyundai lists as little as 7 h 20 min for a 10–100% charge with the standard 10.9 kW onboard charger. The charge windows and battery sizes differ, so these times don't show which adds range faster. Check your home charging setup before you buy.

IONIQ 5 reviewers report lower range in cold weather and at sustained highway speeds. Plan for that with either model in a Canadian winter.

Driving Experience & Ride Quality

The two feel different on the road. Reviewers describe the Model Y as sharp and responsive, with quick steering. The IONIQ 5 comes across as relaxed and steady, not sporty.

The biggest change in the latest Model Y is its ride. Almost every Model Y reviewer says it is much softer and less crashy than the previous version. Several still find it firm over sharp bumps. One owner rates it clearly better but not as smooth as a car with adaptive suspension.

IONIQ 5 reviews include less real driving. Those that do describe a comfortable ride that copes well with rough roads and long trips. Two of the three IONIQ 5 reviews with real driving used versions not sold in Canada, one with firmer suspension. Treat the ride comparison as a modest difference.

Opinions on steering are split for both. Model Y reviewers praise how quickly it turns in. Consumer Reports found the steering short on natural feel. IONIQ 5 reviewers are divided between well weighted and too light.

Both are quiet at highway speeds. Model Y reviewers credit new acoustic glass and better sealing for a big improvement over the previous version. One reviewer still heard the motor under hard acceleration. IONIQ 5 reviewers describe a consistently quiet cabin.

Both offer strong regenerative braking. The Model Y's one-pedal driving is always on, with a standard and a reduced setting, and reviewers find it smooth once you are used to it. The IONIQ 5 has steering-wheel paddles with several regen levels and a one-pedal mode.

Neither is slow. One owner with a RWD version not sold in Canada found even that Model Y quick enough to be fun. None of these driving impressions come from the IONIQ 5 N.

Interior, Passenger Space & Practicality

The cabins take very different approaches. The IONIQ 5 has an airy, open layout, a flat floor and a centre console that slides. The Model Y is strictly minimalist, with very few buttons and one large screen.

Both have roomy rear seats. Several Model Y reviewers, including tall passengers, found the rear legroom and headroom generous under the glass roof. One reviewer felt the sloping roofline limits rear headroom, so check this if your passengers are tall. In the IONIQ 5, the rear seat both slides and reclines, which reviewers note is rare in a two-row SUV, and two reviewers fit three adults across it.

Cargo figures are hard to compare directly. Tesla lists 835 L behind the rear seats for the RWD and 822 L for the AWD trims, but doesn't say how it measures them, so they may not line up with Hyundai's numbers. Hyundai lists 745 L behind the rear seats and 1,655 L with them folded for the IONIQ 5, and 740 L and 1,680 L for the N. Model Y reviewers praise the deep storage well under the cargo floor and the usable front trunk. On AWD versions, the IONIQ 5's front trunk is small.

The Model Ys reviewed have power-folding rear seats. Reviewers like how quickly they fold. Consumer Reports found the cargo cover flimsy, though two owners note it now stows under the cargo floor. IONIQ 5 reviewers like the low, square load floor.

In the Model Y, reviewers like the large door pockets and the two wireless phone chargers. Two found the deep centre bin awkward to reach into, and two owners call the glove box very small. IONIQ 5 reviewers praise the sliding console and the large open area under it.

Materials in the latest Model Y are a clear step up from before, according to several reviewers. They mention more soft-touch surfaces and better fit. Two owners still report delivery flaws, including a scratch and a dent. IONIQ 5 reviewers point to harder plastics lower down in the cabin.

Some Model Y reviewers say the glass roof lets in a lot of heat on sunny days, and some owners add shades. Visibility forward is good in both. Model Y reviewers note wide windshield pillars and a narrow rear window. One IONIQ 5 reviewer praises its all-round visibility, and the IONIQ 5 cars reviewed had a rear wiper.

Technology, Infotainment & Driver Assistance

This is the clearest difference between the two. The Model Y puts almost every control on its central touchscreen. That includes climate, mirrors, the glove box and even the gear selector. The IONIQ 5 keeps physical buttons for key functions, including seat heating and a volume knob.

Model Y reviewers praise the screen and software. They call it fast, smooth and logical once you learn it. Several also find it distracting while driving, with small icons and too many steps for simple tasks. One reviewer found it awkward to turn on the seat ventilation without also switching on the climate system.

The Model Ys reviewed do not offer Apple CarPlay or Android Auto. Reviewers note wireless versions of both in the IONIQ 5. If you rely on your phone's apps in the car, this may decide it.

Shifting on the Model Y is done by swiping on the screen. An auto-shift feature guesses the direction you want. Reviewers say it works most of the time but not always. They welcome the return of a turn-signal stalk. Consumer Reports found that it cancels the signal automatically, which can be awkward when changing several lanes.

IONIQ 5 menus split opinion: some reviewers find them quick, others confusing. The touch-sensitive climate buttons bother one reviewer, while another is fine with them because they sit on their own display.

On the highway, reviewers of both models found the adaptive cruise and lane centring smooth. Tesla's optional self-driving package costs extra. Reviewers who tried it were impressed but stress that it needs constant supervision. Model Y reviewers also praise Tesla's phone app and the camera views.

Exterior Design, Body Style & Size

The IONIQ 5 has a boxy, retro-futuristic look that reviewers call eye-catching but polarizing. The latest Model Y adds slim light bars front and rear, and most reviewers find it sharper and more modern than before. One reviewer dislikes its aero wheel covers.

Both are two-row, five-seat crossovers. The Model Y is longer and a little wider. The IONIQ 5 has the longer wheelbase, which helps explain its roomy rear seat. Their heights are close. These comparisons use the dimensions listed for the IONIQ 5 Preferred Long Range RWD and the Model Y RWD.

One reviewer said the IONIQ 5 feels SUV-sized inside without feeling big to drive. One reviewer found its long wheelbase makes tight parking a little tricky. The Model Y has a front bumper camera that one owner finds helpful when parking near curbs.

What to Check on a Test Drive

  • The Model Y's touchscreen controls and on-screen shifting, during a real drive.
  • Phone connection. Check whether you need Apple CarPlay or Android Auto.
  • Rear-seat space and cargo loading in both, with your usual gear.
  • The ride on rough pavement, in the trim and on the wheel size you would actually buy.
  • Rear visibility in both, and heat under the Model Y's glass roof on a sunny day.
  • Regenerative braking and one-pedal driving in both.

Ready to compare them in person?

Hyundai IONIQ 5Book a Test Drive
Tesla Model YBook a Test Drive

Notes

  • The Model Y's DC fast-charging times are estimates. Tesla does not publish a DC charging time.
  • Model Y Level 2 times are NRCan's full-charge figures.
  • Tesla quotes the Model Y Performance AWD's 0–100 km/h time with rollout subtracted, so it is not measured on the same basis as the IONIQ 5 N's figure.

Prices, trims and specs come from EVSearch's Canadian vehicle data. Driving impressions summarize published expert reviews. Prices are MSRP before freight, fees, taxes and incentives.

Compare

Book a test drive

    I'm interested in:












    To find your nearest dealer.



    By submitting, you agree that EVSearch and its partners may contact you about this request. PrivacyTerms