Tesla Model 3 vs Tesla Model Y

Model 3 vs Model Y: how Tesla's sedan and crossover compare for Canadian buyers on price, range, charging, space and driving feel.

Updated

At a Glance

The Tesla Model 3 and Tesla Model Y share much of their hardware. Each lists three Canadian trims, a choice of RWD or AWD, a 64 kWh or 82 kWh battery and the same listed Level 2 time. The Model 3 Performance lists 394 kW against 380 kW for the Model Y Performance. The real choice is body style. The Model 3 is a low sedan with a separate trunk. The Model Y is a taller crossover SUV with a rear hatch and more cargo room. The Model 3 lists equal or more range at every step of the lineup.

Tesla Model 3 vs Tesla Model Y at a glance
Tesla Model 3Tesla Model Y
MSRP range (CAD)$39,490–$74,990$49,990–$74,990
Canadian trims33
Body styleSedanSUV
DrivetrainRWD or AWDRWD or AWD
Battery64–82 kWh64–82 kWh
Range463–570 km463–542 km
Power208–394 kW220–380 kW
0–100 km/h3.1–6.2 s3.5–7.2 s
Height1,431–1,440 mm1,611–1,624 mm
DC fast charging25–27 min (estimate)24–27 min (estimate)
Level 2 charging8 h8 h

Estimate

Tesla Model 3

The Model 3 is Tesla's electric sedan and the lowest-priced way into the brand in Canada. The range runs from the Premium RWD to the Performance AWD. The refreshed car rides with less harshness than before and is noticeably quieter inside. It still feels agile and quick to respond, thanks to its low stance. Its rear seat has a fold-down armrest and a touchscreen of its own, and it carries cargo in a powered trunk and a front trunk.

Tesla Model Y

The Model Y is the crossover sibling, built on a longer wheelbase with a much taller body. Canadian buyers choose from RWD, Premium AWD and Performance AWD. Its strengths are an upright seating position and a cargo area reached through a rear hatch. It rides more comfortably than the earlier Model Y, with steering that stays quick for an SUV. It keeps a stalk for the turn signals, which the Model 3 does not.

Choose the Tesla Model 3 if you want the lowest entry point, the most range in either lineup and a lower, sportier drive, and a sedan trunk is enough for your cargo.

Choose the Tesla Model Y if you want a higher seating position, a rear hatch and more cargo space behind the rear seats, and you are happy to trade a little range for a more practical body.

Trim Comparison by Budget

About $39,000 to $50,000: Entry trims and long-range AWD

TrimMSRP (CAD)DrivetrainBatteryRangePowerTorque0–100 km/hDC fast chargingLevel 2 charging
Model 3 Premium RWD$39,490RWD64 kWh463 km208 kW404 Nm6.2 s25 min (estimate)8 h
Model 3 Premium AWD$49,990AWD82 kWh570 km280 kW510 Nm4.0 s27 min (estimate)8 h
Model Y RWD$49,990RWD64 kWh463 km220 kW404 Nm7.2 s24 min (estimate)8 h

Estimate

What stands out

  • If price comes first, the Model 3 Premium RWD is the lowest-priced trim in either lineup, $10,500 (21.0%) below the other two trims in this band.
  • The Model 3 Premium RWD and Model Y RWD use the same battery and list the same range and torque. The Model Y RWD lists 12 kW more power, but the Model 3 Premium RWD is a second quicker to 100 km/h.
  • The Model 3 Premium AWD and Model Y RWD have the same MSRP, so this is where body style decides. The Model 3 Premium AWD adds AWD, the larger battery and 107 km more range, the most of any trim in either lineup. The Model Y RWD gives you the taller crossover body.
  • If you want AWD in this band, only the Model 3 Premium AWD offers it, with the quickest 0–100 km/h time here.

About $64,000 to $75,000: Roomy AWD and top performance

TrimMSRP (CAD)DrivetrainBatteryRangePowerTorque0–100 km/hDC fast chargingLevel 2 charging
Model Y Premium AWD$64,990AWD82 kWh542 km296 kW510 Nm4.6 s27 min (estimate)8 h
Model 3 Performance AWD$74,990AWD82 kWh509 km394 kW741 Nm (estimate)3.1 s27 min (estimate)8 h
Model Y Performance AWD$74,990AWD82 kWh494 km380 kW674 Nm3.5 s27 min (estimate)8 h

Estimate

What stands out

  • If you want an AWD crossover with the most range, the Model Y Premium AWD lists 542 km, the most of any Model Y and the most in this band. It is $10,000 (13.3%) below either Performance trim.
  • The two Performance trims have the same MSRP. The Model 3 Performance AWD lists 14 kW more, is quicker to 100 km/h and goes 15 km farther. The Model Y Performance AWD gives you the higher, more practical body.
  • Within the Model Y lineup, the Performance AWD adds 84 kW and cuts more than a second from the 0–100 km/h time, but lists 48 km less range than the Premium AWD.

EVSearch Verdict

Vehicle-level guidance

Lean toward the Model 3 if you want the most range for each kilowatt-hour, the lowest way into a Tesla and a low, agile sedan that suits commuting and highway trips. Lean toward the Model Y if you carry bulky gear, want to sit higher or prefer loading through a hatch. Both share Tesla's software and Supercharger access, so your choice comes down to body style, space and how much range you need.

Recommended trims

  • Lowest price: Model 3 Premium RWD. No trim in either lineup costs less, and its range matches the Model Y RWD.
  • Most range: Model 3 Premium AWD. It lists the most range of any trim here, with AWD and a quick 0–100 km/h time.
  • Lowest-priced Model Y: Model Y RWD. It brings the crossover body and hatch at the lowest Model Y price.
  • Most-range Model Y: Model Y Premium AWD. It pairs AWD with the most range of any Model Y.
  • Quickest: Model 3 Performance AWD. It has the quickest 0–100 km/h time of either lineup and more range than the Model Y Performance AWD.

Final buying guidance

  • Start with what you carry. If a sedan trunk and front trunk cover your week, the Model 3 gets more range from each battery.
  • If you mainly drive alone or as a couple on long highway runs, the Model 3's lower energy use helps. For family duty, the Model Y's height and hatch matter more.
  • Within each lineup, the AWD trims add the larger battery as well as a second motor. Weigh that range gain, not just the traction.
  • For a side-by-side look at range, power and charging across the trims you are weighing, use the EVSearch comparison tool.
Tesla Model 3 on the road
Tesla Model 3
Tesla Model Y on the road
Tesla Model Y

Range, Battery & Charging

The Model 3 goes farther on the same battery. Both RWD trims use a 64 kWh battery and list 463 km, but the AWD and Performance trims share an 82 kWh battery and the Model 3 pulls ahead there. The Model 3 Premium AWD lists 570 km against 542 km for the Model Y Premium AWD. The Model 3 Performance AWD lists 509 km against 494 km for the Model Y Performance AWD.

Energy use explains the gap. Every Model 3 trim lists slightly lower combined energy use than the matching Model Y, and the difference is largest between the two Premium AWD trims. The Model 3's lower body has less frontal area to push through the air.

Every trim of both lists 8 hours on Level 2. That figure covers a 64 kWh and an 82 kWh battery alike, so it does not show which model adds range faster. What it does tell you is that any trim can refill overnight on a home charger. The EVSearch charging cost calculator can help you estimate what that costs where you live.

The DC fast-charging times in the tables are estimates for all six trims. Treat them as a rough guide rather than a way to pick between the two.

Road trips work the same way in both. Each car's navigation plans DC fast-charging stops along a route based on your state of charge. Reviewers of both describe the Supercharger network as dependable: you plug in, and charging starts without a card or a separate app.

Model 3 reviewers note that you cannot turn off one-pedal driving. One reviewer found that tiring on the highway. A Model Y reviewer says it now offers two regenerative braking levels.

Driving Experience & Ride Quality

The Model 3 is the more athletic of the two. It sits lower, and at every step of the lineup it is quicker to 100 km/h than the matching Model Y. Model 3 reviewers describe quick, direct steering, little body roll and an eager feel on winding roads. One reviewer says the AWD version feels so nimble it makes him drive faster than he would in almost any other car.

Tesla Model 3 on the road
Tesla Model 3
Tesla Model Y on the road
Tesla Model Y

The Model Y trades some of that for comfort and height. A Model Y owner who also drives a Model 3 found the Model Y feels a little floatier because you sit higher, though its ride was on par with his own Model 3. One consumer magazine describes the Model Y's handling as slightly dulled by its softer setup, but still quick to respond.

Both rides improved with the most recent updates. Model 3 reviewers say the refreshed sedan absorbs bumps far better than the version before it. One reviewer notes the RWD version's front end can bounce over rough surfaces. The Model 3 Performance AWD adds adaptive dampers, and one reviewer calls its ride plush for such a fast car. Model Y owners also report a calmer ride than before, but one would still like adaptive dampers for rough roads.

Cabin noise is close. Model 3 reviewers praise the double-glazed windows and say the cabin is far quieter than before. A Model Y owner who also drives a Model 3 found road noise about the same in both.

On the Performance trims, the Model 3 Performance AWD is the one built for keen drivers. Reviewers describe huge grip, more supportive seats and a track mode. One reviewer found no track mode on the Model Y Performance. Another reviewer felt the Model 3 Performance could still be more involving.

Interior, Passenger Space & Practicality

Cargo space is where the Model Y earns its place. The Model 3 has 594 L of trunk space behind the rear seats. The Model Y lists 822 to 835 L depending on trim, rising to 2,004 to 2,022 L with the rear seats folded. One consumer magazine names the cargo area as one of the main reasons to choose the Model Y over the Model 3.

Tesla Model 3 dashboard
Tesla Model 3
Tesla Model Y dashboard
Tesla Model Y

Loading is different too. The Model 3's power trunk lid leaves an oddly upright opening, because the rear glass runs far back. The Model Y opens as a full hatch. Model Y reviewers like the rear seats that fold and rise at the push of a button. Both add a deep under-floor bin and a front trunk, and one Model Y reviewer calls its front trunk big.

Seating position separates them. A consumer magazine found the Model 3 driving position a little cramped, with your feet high because of the floor-mounted battery, and preferred the Model Y's upright SUV stance. Model Y passengers in the rear also sit higher, and one owner liked that view.

Rear space suits adults in both. Model 3 reviewers find good knee room and a flat floor. Two say taller passengers can touch the glass roof, and one found his knees raised because the floor sits high. The Model Y's taller body gives more headroom. A six-foot Model Y reviewer described rear headroom as excellent.

Reviewers of both describe ventilated front seats and a rear touchscreen for climate and media. Model 3 reviewers like the softer materials and fabric-lined storage of the refreshed cabin. One notes the glass roof has no sunshade, so the cabin can get hot.

Technology, Infotainment & Driver Assistance

The two share the same software, Tesla app and phone-as-key access. Reviewers of both describe the same centre touchscreen size on both, with a larger screen on the Model Y Performance. Reviewers of both call the system quick and full of features, from games and streaming to camping and pet climate modes.

Neither has a driver display behind the wheel or a head-up display. Your speed shows on the centre screen, which several Model 3 reviewers dislike. Neither offers Apple CarPlay or Android Auto.

Controls differ in one way that matters to many drivers. The Model 3 uses buttons on the steering wheel for the turn signals, and several reviewers find that awkward, especially on roundabouts. The Model Y has a turn-signal stalk. Both select drive and reverse on the screen.

Reviewers of both describe adaptive cruise control and steering assistance as standard. Tesla's Full Self-Driving system is an extra-cost option. Reviewers of both note there is no 360-degree camera view, and one reviewer found the camera-only parking system less sure around small objects.

Exterior Design, Body Style & Size

The Model 3 is a low, sleek sedan. Its refresh brought slimmer headlights and a new rear light design, and the Performance version adds a front splitter, a carbon spoiler and wider tires at the rear than at the front.

Tesla Model 3 rear
Tesla Model 3
Tesla Model Y rear
Tesla Model Y

The Model Y is the electric SUV of the pair. Compared with the RWD versions, it is 181 mm taller, 77 mm longer and 70 mm wider than the Model 3, on a 15 mm longer wheelbase. A Model Y owner notes it no longer looks like a stretched Model 3, with its own front and rear lighting.

That extra height is the trade-off. It brings the higher seating position and larger cargo area, but the Model 3's lower body is why it uses less energy and feels more agile. Reviewers of both mention thick front pillars, and the Model Y's rear window is narrow. Model 3 reviewers say its cameras help make up for the limited rear view.

What to Check on a Test Drive

  • The turn-signal buttons in the Model 3, if you drive on roundabouts or winding roads.
  • The driving position in each, especially if you prefer to sit higher.
  • Rear headroom under the glass roof if your passengers are tall.
  • How your stroller, sports gear or luggage fits in the Model 3's trunk opening.
  • The ride on your local roads, and on the Performance wheels if you are considering one.

Ready to compare them in person?

Tesla Model 3Book a Test Drive
Tesla Model YBook a Test Drive

Notes

  • The DC fast-charging times for all trims and the Model 3 Performance AWD torque are estimates.
  • Some reviews summarized here cover versions sold outside Canada. Some Model 3 reviews cover trims not sold in Canada, so their range and charging impressions are not used.

Prices, trims and specs come from EVSearch's Canadian vehicle data. Driving impressions summarize published expert reviews. Prices are MSRP before freight, fees, taxes and incentives.

Compare

Book a test drive

    I'm interested in:












    To find your nearest dealer.



    By submitting, you agree that EVSearch and its partners may contact you about this request. PrivacyTerms